Pin it
There's something irresistibly comforting about biting into a perfectly grilled Reuben sandwich. The combination of tender corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and creamy thousand island dressing, all embraced by crispy rye bread, creates a symphony of flavors that's stood the test of time since its New York City origins.
Every time I make these sandwiches for my family gatherings, they disappear within minutes. The smell of butter-toasted rye bread brings everyone to the kitchen without fail.
Essential Ingredients and Selection Tips
- Dark Rye Bread: Choose sturdy, fresh bread with visible seeds; it needs strength to hold the filling
- Corned Beef: Opt for freshly sliced from the deli counter, medium thickness works best
- Sauerkraut: Look for refrigerated varieties for the best texture and tanginess
- Swiss Cheese: Fresh-shredded melts better than pre-packaged
- Thousand Island Dressing: Homemade or quality store-bought both work beautifully
- Butter: Unsalted allows better control of the overall saltiness
Detailed Cooking Instructions
- Step 1: Sandwich Assembly
- - Start with room temperature ingredients for even heating
- Layer ingredients in this order: bread, cheese, dressing, corned beef, sauerkraut
- Press gently to compact ingredients without squishing
- Butter the outside of both bread slices evenly - Step 2: Perfect Grilling Technique
- - Heat skillet to medium (never high) for even melting
- Place sandwich butter-side down first
- Press gently with spatula for even browning
- Cook until golden brown (about 3 minutes per side)
- Flip carefully to maintain filling integrity
Growing up, my grandmother would always add extra sauerkraut to her Reuben. She swore by its digestive benefits and would tell stories of how her mother made it from scratch in wooden barrels.
Temperature Control Matters
The key to a perfect Reuben lies in temperature management. Too hot, and you'll burn the bread before the cheese melts. Too cool, and you'll end up with a soggy sandwich. I've found that maintaining medium heat allows the cheese to melt perfectly while the bread achieves that gorgeous golden-brown color.
Storage and Make-Ahead Tips
While Reubens are best enjoyed fresh off the griddle, you can prep components ahead of time. Store your ingredients separately in the refrigerator, but always bring the corned beef to room temperature before assembling. This small step makes a noticeable difference in the final product.
Variations and Customizations
The classic Reuben is perfect as is, but don't be afraid to make it your own. Try using pastrami instead of corned beef for a smokier flavor, or experiment with different mustards alongside the thousand island dressing. Some of my readers have even reported success using turkey for a lighter version, though purists might disagree with calling it a Reuben at that point.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What kind of bread is best for a Reuben sandwich?
- Dark or regular rye bread is recommended as it provides structure and flavor to hold the sandwich ingredients.
- → Can I use pastrami instead of corned beef?
- Yes, pastrami is a great alternative to corned beef and tastes delicious in a Reuben sandwich.
- → How can I avoid a soggy Reuben sandwich?
- Make sure to drain the sauerkraut thoroughly before using it and toast the sandwich properly.
- → What’s the best cheese for a Reuben sandwich?
- Swiss cheese is traditionally used for its mild, creamy flavor and great melting properties.
- → Can I make the sandwich ahead of time?
- It’s best to prepare and toast the sandwich fresh, but you can store the ingredients separately for convenience.