Pin it
I'm thrilled to share my treasured Butterscotch Pie recipe with you! After years of tweaking and testing in my kitchen I've created the silkiest most indulgent butterscotch filling you can imagine. This pie holds such special memories for me nestled in a perfectly flaky crust and crowned with clouds of fresh whipped cream. Every bite brings you that old fashioned butterscotch flavor that just can't be matched with instant pudding.
What Makes This Recipe Special
You know those desserts that transport you straight back to grandma's kitchen? This is one of those! My readers tell me this pie brings back cherished memories while creating new ones. The magic lies in making everything from scratch letting those caramel notes develop slowly. Plus you can make it ahead which is perfect for busy holiday seasons or dinner parties.
Let's Gather Our Ingredients
- Pie Crust: My buttery homemade crust recipe makes all the difference here trust me.
- Dark Brown Sugar: This is our star ingredient giving us that deep rich butterscotch flavor.
- Egg Yolks: These golden beauties create the smoothest custard imaginable.
- Heavy Cream: Don't even think about substituting this is where our luxurious texture comes from.
- Vanilla Extract: A splash of vanilla or rum adds such wonderful depth.
Let's Make Magic
- Starting with the Perfect Crust
- First things first let's blind bake our crust until it's golden and flaky. I always chill my dough twice and use pie weights they're absolute game changers.
- Creating Liquid Gold
- Now for my favorite part! Watch closely as your sugar transforms into amber caramel. When you add the cream it'll bubble and sputter like a science experiment pure kitchen magic!
- Making the Silkiest Filling
- Here's where patience pays off. Keep whisking that caramel into your brown sugar egg mixture. The key is maintaining the perfect temperature between 195°F and 200°F. I keep my thermometer clipped to the pot.
- The Final Steps
- Pour that velvety custard into your waiting crust. Now comes the hard part waiting! Give it at least 6 hours in the fridge uncovered. I know it's tempting but trust me on this one.
The Grand Finale
Just before serving I love crowning this beauty with freshly whipped cream sweetened with a touch of brown sugar. Sometimes I get fancy and drizzle warm salted caramel over the top. It's absolutely divine with a cup of strong coffee especially when shared with friends around my kitchen table.
My Best Tips
Let me share some secrets I've learned through countless pies. Take your time with the caramel rushing it leads to bitter disappointment literally! Keep whisking that custard like your life depends on it lumps are not your friend. And please oh please blind bake your crust properly nobody wants a soggy bottom!
Plan Ahead
Here's why I love this recipe for entertaining you can make it two whole days ahead! Just keep it covered in the fridge and add the whipped cream right before your guests arrive. Any leftovers if you're lucky enough to have them will keep beautifully for three days.
Make It Your Own
Sometimes I love adding a splash of bourbon to the custard it adds such warmth. For special occasions I'll sprinkle crushed toffee bits over the top or use fancy muscovado sugar in the filling. Each twist makes it feel new and exciting!
Serving Your Masterpiece
Want to really wow your guests? Serve each slice with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream and fresh berries. The contrast between warm and cold creamy and fresh is absolutely stunning. When I'm hosting dinner parties I love pairing it with dessert wine the flavors dance together beautifully.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make this pie ahead of time?
Yes, this pie needs at least 6 hours to set and can be made up to 2 days ahead. The crust can be made 3 days ahead and the completed pie can be frozen for up to 3 months.
- → Can I use a graham cracker crust instead?
No, a crumb crust is not recommended as it won't hold up under the creamy filling. A traditional flaky pie crust is necessary for this recipe.
- → Why do ingredients need to be room temperature?
Room temperature ingredients blend more smoothly and help prevent the custard from curdling when combined. This ensures a silky smooth filling texture.
- → Can I use different milk or cream?
No, whole milk and heavy cream are essential for proper setting. Low-fat or non-dairy alternatives will not work in this recipe.
- → How do I know when the filling is done cooking?
The filling is done when it reaches 195-200°F and large bubbles burst on the surface. Using a thermometer ensures perfect results.
Conclusion
This homemade butterscotch pie features a silky pudding filling made from scratch with caramelized sugar, topped with brown sugar whipped cream in a flaky pie crust.