Ultimate Grilled Cheese

Let me share my absolute favorite way to make the ultimate comfort food - a sourdough grilled cheese that'll change how you think about this classic sandwich! After years of perfecting this recipe I've discovered the secret to getting that perfectly crispy outside while keeping the inside gorgeously gooey. Trust me this isn't your average grilled cheese.

Why Sourdough Makes It Special

You know what makes this grilled cheese extraordinary? That tangy sourdough bread adds such amazing flavor and it gets perfectly crispy without falling apart. Plus it stands up beautifully to all that melty cheese! I love how versatile it is whether I'm dunking it in tomato soup or enjoying it on its own.

Let's Gather Our Ingredients

• The Bread: Two nice thick slices of sourdough you want them about ½ inch.
• The Fats: Room temperature butter and my secret weapon - a little mayonnaise.
• The Stars: Freshly grated cheddar for that sharp flavor and gruyère for extra creaminess.

Let's Make It Together

Get Your Pan Ready

First things first get that cast iron skillet warming up on low heat. Patience here is key - we want it to heat evenly.

Prep Your Bread

Here's my secret trick spread a thin layer of mayo on one side of each slice. I know it sounds weird but trust me it makes the most amazing golden crust!

Cheese Time

Always grate your cheese fresh it melts so much better than pre-shredded. Mix those two cheeses together they're about to become best friends.

Building Magic

Once your butter's melted in the pan lay down that first slice mayo-side down pile on your cheese then top with the other slice mayo-side up.

The Perfect Cook

Cover it up and let it do its thing for about 2-3 minutes. When you peek under and see that golden brown color it's time to flip! Another couple minutes and you're golden literally.

Pin it

My Best Tips

Here's what I've learned from making countless grilled cheese sandwiches: keep that heat low and steady rushing only leads to burnt bread and unmelted cheese. Always grate your cheese fresh and don't be afraid to try different combinations. That mayo trick? It gives you the most amazing golden brown crust every time.

Make It Your Own

Let me share some of my favorite ways to dress up this sandwich! Sometimes I'll add a layer of caramelized onions they get all sweet and jammy. A spread of fig jam makes it feel fancy or try some thin apple slices for crunch. My latest obsession? A drizzle of hot honey right before serving it's like a flavor explosion!

Common Questions Answered

People always ask me how to avoid soggy bread - thick slices of sourdough and low heat are your friends here. If you've got leftovers (which rarely happens in my house!) wrap them in foil and reheat in a toaster oven never the microwave. And for that Instagram-worthy cheese pull add a bit of mozzarella to your mix.

Mix Up Your Cheese Game

Want to know what cheese combinations I love? Sharp cheddar and gruyère is my go-to but sometimes I'll mix it up with some creamy Monterey Jack or aged gouda. Feeling fancy? Add a slice of brie it gets so wonderfully gooey. The key is balancing flavors and meltability.

Perfect Pairings

My favorite way to serve this grilled cheese? Alongside a steaming bowl of tomato soup - it's a classic for a reason! When I'm feeling fancy I'll make a little green salad with a tangy vinaigrette. And don't forget the pickles! That briny crunch adds such a nice contrast to all that creamy cheese.

Saving It For Later

If you happen to have leftovers (though in my house they disappear fast!) wrap them in foil and pop them in the fridge. They'll keep for a couple days but here's the trick - reheat them in a toaster oven or back in the skillet. The microwave just makes them sad and soggy and nobody wants that!

Taking It Up A Notch

Want to make your sandwich extra special? Try brushing the inside with a tiny bit of truffle oil before adding the cheese or sprinkle some flaky sea salt on the crust right when it comes out of the pan. These little touches make it feel like something from a fancy café!

Avoid These Common Mistakes

Let me share what I've learned from my grilled cheese adventures. First never use bread that's too thin it'll fall apart under all that cheese. Second stay away from pre-shredded cheese - those anti-caking agents prevent that perfect melt we're looking for. And always keep your heat low and steady patience makes perfect!

The Perfect Cheese Pull

Want to know my secret for those amazing stretchy cheese pulls? Add a layer of mozzarella in with your other cheeses. Then here's the trick: after you slice the sandwich add a tiny bit more cheese and give it just another minute in the pan. When you pull those pieces apart it's pure photo-worthy magic!

Fun Ways to Switch It Up

The possibilities are endless with this sandwich! Sometimes I'll add a layer of caramelized onions they get all sweet and lovely. A schmear of fig jam takes it in a whole new direction. And when I'm feeling fancy a few thin slices of Granny Smith apple add the perfect tart crunch. Don't even get me started on the magic of hot honey drizzled on top!

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Why use mayonnaise on the outside?

Mayo helps create an evenly golden, crispy crust. It spreads easily and has a higher smoke point than butter.

→ Can I use pre-grated cheese?

Fresh grated cheese melts better and more evenly. Pre-grated cheese often contains anti-caking agents that affect melting.

→ Why cook on low heat?

Low heat ensures the cheese melts completely while the bread gets golden brown. High heat can burn the bread before the cheese melts.

→ What can I substitute for sourdough?

Any sturdy bread works, but sourdough's tang and structure make it ideal. Country white or whole grain are good alternatives.

→ Why use two types of cheese?

Cheddar provides sharp flavor while gruyère adds nutty taste and superior melting qualities. Together they create the perfect balance.