Pin it
A perfectly golden grilled cheese is one of life's simple pleasures and after years of making them I've discovered all the little secrets that make them absolutely incredible. That moment when you cut into a perfectly toasted sandwich and the cheese stretches into gorgeous strings well it just doesn't get better than that.
What Makes This Recipe Special
I've found that using mayo instead of butter on the outside creates the most amazing golden crust while a touch of Dijon adds wonderful depth. My favorite cheese combo of sharp cheddar with Gruyère or raclette melts into pure heaven. The trick of covering the pan? That's what gives you that perfect gooey center every time.
Ingredients for Perfect Grilled Cheese
- Good bread: I love sourdough for extra flavor but good white bread makes a classic version.
- Mayonnaise: Trust me this creates the most incredible crispy outside.
- Dijon mustard: Just a touch adds such lovely flavor.
- Butter: A little in the pan makes everything better.
- Cheese: That cheddar Gruyère combo is pure magic when melted.
How to Make It
- Prepare the bread
- Spread your mayo on the outside Dijon on the inside of one slice.
- Add cheese
- Pile that freshly grated cheese mixture on top and close it up mayo side out.
- Heat the pan
- Get your buttered pan warm over medium low heat pop the lid on for perfect melting.
- Cook and flip
- Give it about 2 3 minutes each side watching carefully for that golden color.
Fun Ways to Mix It Up
Sometimes I add gouda or fontina for a change or tuck in some caramelized onions. Brie with apple slices is heavenly and pickled jalapeños add such a nice kick. A swipe of pesto can transform the whole sandwich into something new.
My Best Tips
Always grate your own cheese it melts so much better. My cast iron pan makes the perfect crust. Keep that heat on the lower side and don't forget the lid trick. Let it rest just a minute before cutting those perfect gooey triangles.
Perfect Pairings
Nothing beats dunking these into creamy tomato soup. A fresh green salad on the side keeps things light or go all in with some crunchy chips. Sometimes I serve them with marinara or hot honey for dipping pure comfort food heaven.
Pin it
Keeping Them Fresh
If you happen to have leftovers they'll keep in the fridge for a couple days. Reheat them in a skillet or air fryer to keep that crispy outside. Skip the microwave though it just makes them soggy. But honestly they're best fresh off the pan when that cheese is perfectly melted.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why use mayonnaise on the outside?
- Mayo helps achieve a perfectly golden-brown, crispy exterior better than butter alone.
- → Why use two types of cheese?
- Sharp cheddar provides flavor while Gruyère or raclette adds excellent melting qualities and depth of taste.
- → Why cook on medium-low heat?
- Lower heat allows the cheese to melt completely while the bread achieves the perfect golden-brown color without burning.
- → Why cover while cooking?
- The lid helps trap heat, ensuring the cheese melts thoroughly before the bread gets too brown.
- → Can I use different bread?
- While sourdough is recommended for its flavor and texture, any sturdy bread will work.