Pin it
These Christmas thumbprint cookies bring back so many sweet memories. I make them every year the buttery dough that's crisp outside and tender inside just melts in your mouth. What I love most is how easy they are to whip up no chilling needed and they stay fresh for days. They're my go to for cookie boxes and edible gifts everyone lights up when they see them.
What Makes These Cookies Special
The beauty of these cookies is how versatile they are. One batch can become so many different treats chocolate peppermint classic raspberry whatever you're craving. When holiday rush hits these are my secret weapon they come together so quickly. The texture is just perfect sturdy enough to pack up as gifts but still wonderfully soft. Once you try them they'll become your holiday favorite too.
Everything You'll Need
- Butter: This creates that rich melt in your mouth base you'll love.
- Brown and Granulated Sugar: The perfect combo for sweetness and amazing texture.
- Flour: Regular all purpose flour keeps everything together beautifully.
- Cocoa Powder: Just for those chocolate lovers out there.
- Baking Powder: The secret to keeping these cookies perfectly soft.
- Egg and Vanilla: These bring everything together with wonderful flavor.
- Fillings: Go wild here jam lemon curd Nutella whatever makes you happy.
- Toppings: Sprinkle with sugar nuts coconut or crushed candies for extra sparkle.
Let's Make Some Cookies
- Start With The Basics
- First cream together your butter sugars and vanilla until fluffy. Add the egg then mix in flour and baking powder. Want chocolate ones? Just add cocoa to half the dough.
- Shape Your Cookies
- Roll your dough into cute little balls coat them in sugar or your favorite toppings then make those signature thumbprints in the center.
- Time to Fill and Bake
- Add your favorite fillings like jam right now but save things like Nutella for later. Pop them in a 355°F oven for 8 to 10 minutes.
- Finishing Touches
- Let them cool on a rack then add any final toppings. Now try not to eat them all at once.
My Best Baking Tips
Want to know my secrets for perfect thumbprints? Don't overmix that dough we want them soft and tender. Pull them from the oven while the centers still look slightly underdone they'll finish setting up as they cool. Rolling them in sugar before shaping helps prevent sticking and wait until after baking to add any chocolate toppings.
Keep Them Fresh
These beauties stay fresh in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 4 days. Need to make them last longer? Pop them in the freezer for up to 2 months. Just skip refrigerating the raw dough it gets too hard to work with and might crack when you shape it.
Not Your Average Christmas Cookie
The real magic of these thumbprints is how many different cookies you can create from one simple recipe. Fill holiday cookie boxes with an array of flavors or set out a platter that wows your guests. Since there's no chilling time required you can have fresh cookies ready whenever the craving hits. That perfect combo of crisp edges and soft centers keeps everyone coming back for more.
Mix Up The Flavors
Get creative with your flavors chocolate peppermint is always a hit and lemon curd adds such brightness. Top them with crushed candy canes coconut or festive sprinkles to match your holiday theme. My family loves when I fill them with Nutella or cookie butter but classic raspberry jam never disappoints.
Perfect Pairings
These cookies shine on any holiday dessert platter especially alongside a steaming mug of hot cocoa or spiced mulled wine. Mix them with gingerbread and shortbread for the ultimate Christmas cookie spread. Pack them in pretty boxes tied with ribbon they make the sweetest gifts.
Final Touches
Give your cookies room to spread about 2 inches apart on the baking sheet. Keep those dough balls consistent in size for even baking. Always start with a hot oven and line your baking sheets with parchment it makes cleanup so much easier. Have fun playing with different toppings to make them extra festive.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why shouldn't I make the dough ahead of time?
- Refrigerated dough becomes difficult to work with - sugar won't stick on the outside, cookies aren't as soft, and they're more prone to cracking. Best to make and bake same day.
- → When should I add different types of fillings?
- Add jams and curds before baking. Add chocolate, Nutella, or Hershey's kisses after baking while cookies are still hot to prevent burning or crusting.
- → How long do these cookies keep?
- Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 4 days. Storage time may vary depending on fillings used.
- → Can I make these all chocolate?
- Yes, the recipe lets you split the dough and make half vanilla, half chocolate, or you can add cocoa to the entire batch for all chocolate cookies.
- → Why coat the cookies before making indentations?
- Coating in sugar or other toppings prevents the dough from sticking while pressing down to make the thumbprint indentation.