Pin it
I've been baking this pecan pie for years and it never fails to bring smiles to my family's faces! There's something magical about that perfect combination of buttery crust and gooey filling loaded with toasted pecans. Every time I pull this pie from the oven my kitchen fills with the most incredible caramel aroma that takes me right back to my grandmother's holiday table.
What Makes This Recipe Special
Let me tell you why this Pioneer Woman inspired recipe has become my go to! The filling achieves that perfect balance between sweet and nutty while the crust stays wonderfully crisp. I love how the pecans rise to create a beautiful top layer as it bakes. Even my friends who claim they aren't bakers have had success with this foolproof recipe.
What You'll Need
- Unbaked Pie Crust: I always use my favorite all butter recipe it makes such a difference.
- Chopped Pecans: Fresh pecans are worth seeking out for the best flavor.
- Light Corn Syrup: This creates that signature gooey texture we all love.
- Brown Sugar: Dark or light both work beautifully here.
- Eggs: Room temperature eggs blend much better.
- Vanilla: Pure vanilla extract adds such lovely warmth.
Let's Bake Together
- Starting With Your Crust
- Roll out your pie dough nice and thin aiming for about 12 inches to fit your 9 inch pie pan. Take your time with the edges I love creating a pretty fluted pattern.
- Creating That Perfect Filling
- In your mixing bowl combine both sugars salt corn syrup and melted butter until they're smooth and glossy. Beat in those room temperature eggs and vanilla until everything comes together into a silky mixture.
- Building Your Pie
- Scatter those gorgeous pecans all over your prepared crust. I like to arrange a few extra around the edges they get so beautifully toasted! Now pour that sweet filling slowly over the nuts watch how they float to create a perfect top layer.
- Into The Oven
- Cover your pie loosely with foil this prevents the top from getting too dark too quickly. After 30 minutes remove that foil and let it continue baking until it's just slightly jiggly in the center. The filling will keep setting as it cools.
- The Waiting Game
- I know it's tempting but let your pie cool completely! Those few hours of waiting mean perfect slices later. Sometimes I make it the night before just to be sure.
My Best Tips
Here's what I've learned from making countless pecan pies. Always use freshly chopped pecans they really do taste better than pre chopped ones. Don't worry about toasting them first the long bake time takes care of that. And please let it cool completely before cutting your patience will be rewarded with picture perfect slices!
Common Questions Solved
- Help! My filling is runny: Just pop it back in the oven for 5 10 minute intervals until it sets properly.
- Dark or light corn syrup: I love dark for holiday pies it adds such richness!
- Storage secrets: Always refrigerate after it cools completely it keeps the filling perfectly set.
Fun Ways to Mix It Up
- Try it with chocolate: Sprinkle in some chocolate chips for an amazing twist.
- Add some bourbon: A splash makes it feel extra special.
- Go natural: Pure maple syrup creates the most wonderful flavor.
Make It Extra Special
Want to really wow your guests? Serve each slice slightly warm with a generous scoop of vanilla bean ice cream. The way it melts into the warm pie is absolutely heavenly. A drizzle of caramel sauce takes it completely over the top!
Planning Ahead
This pie is perfect for busy holidays! Bake it up to three months ahead wrap it well and freeze. Just remember to thaw it in the fridge overnight before your gathering. The flavor and texture stay absolutely perfect.
A True Southern Classic
There's a reason this recipe has stood the test of time. That perfect balance of sweet filling crunchy nuts and buttery crust just can't be beat. Whether it's Thanksgiving Christmas or just because you need something special this pie never disappoints.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why does the baking time vary so much?
Oven temperatures can vary, and factors like pie pan material and initial ingredient temperature affect baking time. The pie is done when it's not overly jiggly in the center.
- → Why cover with foil while baking?
Foil prevents the crust and pecans from browning too quickly. Removing it partway through allows for even browning without burning.
- → How do I know when the pie is done?
The filling should not be overly jiggly when done. If it shakes a lot, continue baking with foil cover until set.
- → Why serve in thin slivers?
Pecan pie is very rich and sweet. Small slices are more enjoyable and allow more people to enjoy the pie.
- → Can I make this pie ahead?
Yes, the pie needs several hours to cool and set properly. You can make it a day ahead and let it cool overnight.
Conclusion
A classic Southern pecan pie that combines rich, sweet filling with crunchy pecans, perfect for holiday gatherings and special occasions.